Democracy Without Decorum: When Political Self-Interest Devalues Good Governance and Weakens Citizenship
Democracy Without Decorum: When Political Self-Interest Devalues Good Governance and Weakens Citizenship
By Professor Ojo Emmanuel Ademola
Introduction
Nigeria’s democracy is entering another defining season as political actors position themselves ahead of the 2027 general elections. In vibrant democracies, electioneering should strengthen accountability, deepen public engagement, and encourage institutions to perform better. Unfortunately, there is an emerging tendency to reduce every public issue to partisan advantage. This tendency often rewards outrage over evidence and political theatre over civic responsibility. Recent controversies surrounding the Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission, Professor Joash Amupitan, including the confrontation and protest that occurred outside Chatham House in London, have highlighted wider concerns about how democratic disagreements are increasingly being expressed. Democracy certainly permits criticism, protest, and scrutiny. Yet when opposition politics becomes a campaign to discredit institutions regardless of facts, the long-term consequence is a weakening of governance and a decline in public trust. What begins as opposition to individuals can gradually become hostility towards institutions themselves. When that happens, citizens lose confidence, reforms become more difficult, and democracy suffers. The true challenge before Nigeria is therefore not whether criticism should exist, but whether criticism can remain constructive, responsible, and anchored in the national interest.
READ ALSO: Fayose Links Obasanjo’s Attack on Tinubu to Failed Governorship Bid for Daughter
The Growing Temptation to Politicise Every Institution
A healthy democracy requires strong opposition. Governments must be questioned, challenged, and held accountable. However, a distinction must always be maintained between opposing a government and undermining national institutions. Electoral commissions, courts, security agencies, and constitutional bodies belong to the nation, not to any political party. Once every institution becomes a battlefield for political combat, public confidence begins to erode. In recent years, social media has accelerated this problem. Allegations frequently travel faster than verified facts. Public perception is often shaped before investigations are concluded. Under such conditions, institutions can be condemned before evidence is fully examined. The danger is that citizens may become convinced that nothing works, nobody is trustworthy, and every public action hides an ulterior motive. Such a mindset creates fertile ground for cynicism. Democracy cannot flourish indefinitely where cynicism becomes the dominant civic culture.
Democracy Requires Confidence as Well as Criticism
Democratic accountability thrives when citizens remain vigilant, but it also requires a reasonable degree of trust in public institutions. While criticism is necessary to expose failures and prevent abuse, constant suspicion of every institution can weaken the very structures that sustain democratic governance. A mature civic culture balances scrutiny with fairness, ensuring that institutions are judged by evidence rather than political narratives. Without that balance, public confidence diminishes, civic engagement suffers, and democratic progress becomes increasingly difficult to sustain.
The Chatham House Protest and Democratic Responsibility
The protest involving Professor Joash Amupitan outside Chatham House generated significant discussion among Nigerians at home and abroad. Those who participated argued that they were exercising their democratic right to challenge alleged irregularities linked to voter registration and electoral preparations. Every citizen has a legitimate right to demand transparency from public officials. However, democracy requires more than rights; it also requires responsibilities. The line between legitimate protest and actions that may appear intimidating should never be ignored. The ability of citizens to protest must coexist with respect for personal dignity, safety, and due process. Public officials should answer difficult questions, yet accountability is best achieved through lawful engagement, evidence-based advocacy, and institutional mechanisms. Democracies grow stronger when disagreement remains civil. They grow weaker when anger becomes the primary language of political participation. The goal should never be to silence criticism but to ensure that criticism advances reform rather than merely generating spectacle.
Good Governance Needs Fair-Minded Scrutiny
One of the greatest threats to public administration is the assumption that every effort at reform is automatically fraudulent because it originates from an institution under scrutiny. Recent debates relating to voter registration irregularities demonstrate this challenge. Where deficiencies exist, they should be exposed and corrected. Where officials fail, they should be held accountable. Yet where institutions acknowledge problems and implement corrective measures, these efforts should also receive fair recognition. Good governance depends upon continuous improvement. Improvement becomes difficult when institutions are denied credibility even while addressing identified concerns. Constructive scrutiny encourages better performance. Blanket condemnation discourages initiative and may create a defensive bureaucratic culture. Nigeria needs a civic environment where institutions are pressured to improve while also being allowed the legitimacy required to function effectively. Accountability should be rigorous, but it should never become synonymous with permanent institutional distrust.
Institutional Reform Must Be Judged by Results, Not Assumptions
Scepticism is an essential component of democratic accountability, but skepticism must remain evidence-driven. When every corrective action undertaken by a public institution is dismissed as a public relations exercise, meaningful reform becomes increasingly difficult to achieve. The true measure of institutional credibility lies not in assumptions about motive but in demonstrable outcomes. Citizens, civil society organisations, and the media have a responsibility to scrutinise actions carefully, assess progress objectively, and distinguish between genuine reform and mere appearances. This balanced approach strengthens accountability while encouraging institutions to address shortcomings openly. A governance culture that rewards measurable improvement rather than reflexive cynicism is more likely to produce sustainable reforms, stronger public institutions, and greater confidence in the democratic process.
How Democratic Culture Shapes Citizenship
Good citizenship does not begin and end at the ballot box. It includes respect for lawful processes, commitment to truth, tolerance of opposing viewpoints, and a willingness to participate constructively in public life. Citizens often expect integrity from leaders, and rightly so. Yet democracy also requires integrity from citizens. If misinformation is circulated because it supports a preferred narrative, civic responsibility is weakened. If public abuse is celebrated because it targets a disliked official, democratic norms are undermined. Citizenship is ultimately a shared commitment to the common good. Societies prosper when citizens recognise that institutions require both oversight and support. Constantly attacking institutions without evidence may win temporary political points, but it imposes long-term costs on national cohesion. The quality of governance and the quality of citizenship are deeply interconnected. Weak citizenship eventually produces weak governance, just as weak governance can undermine responsible citizenship.
The Cost of Normalising Institutional Distrust
When distrust becomes normalised, every election result is questioned, every reform is dismissed, and every public servant becomes a potential target of suspicion. Such an environment creates instability that extends beyond politics. Investors become cautious, international partners become uncertain, and ordinary citizens become frustrated. Nations develop when institutions steadily accumulate credibility. They stagnate when institutions are repeatedly stripped of legitimacy. Nigeria has made notable democratic progress since 1999. Electoral reforms, technological innovations, and greater citizen participation have all expanded democratic space. While serious challenges remain, these gains deserve recognition. A nation that recognises only its failures eventually loses the confidence required to pursue further progress. Democracy is strengthened neither by blind loyalty nor by relentless hostility. It is strengthened through balanced judgement.
Conclusion
As the 2027 elections approach, Nigeria faces an important democratic test. Citizens must continue demanding transparency, fairness, and accountability from all public institutions. Political actors must retain the freedom to criticise government policies and challenge electoral processes where concerns exist. At the same time, the nation must resist the temptation to convert every disagreement into a campaign against institutional legitimacy. The controversy surrounding Professor Joash Amupitan and the protest outside Chatham House should serve as an opportunity for national reflection. Democracy is strongest when criticism is informed, protests are peaceful, and institutions are judged on evidence rather than emotion. Devaluing good governance in the name of opposition or self-interest may produce short-term political gains, but it ultimately weakens democracy and diminishes citizenship. Nigeria’s future will depend not only on the conduct of elections but also on the civic culture that surrounds them. A mature democracy requires both accountability and restraint, both freedom and responsibility. Preserving that balance is the responsibility of every patriotic citizen.
Professor Ojo Emmanuel Ademola is the first African Professor of Cybersecurity and Information Technology Management, Global Education Advocate, Chartered Manager, UK Digital Journalist, Strategic Advisor & Prophetic Mobiliser for National Transformation, public intellectual, and African governance thinker and General Evangelist of CAC Nigeria and Overseas